Afterlife debate w christopher hitchens, sam harris, rabbi. I agree with openlyatheist that wolpe consistently retreated to a liberal, almost universalist theology as a. Part 1, part 2, part 3, part 4, part 5, part 6 free inquiry articles. Samuel benjamin harris born april 9, 1967 is an american author, philosopher, and neuroscientist. Lecture at new york society for ethical culture november 16, 2005. Once, i moderated a debate between him and rabbi david wolpe on whether religion is good. For other people with the same name, see sam harris disambiguation. In his most recent book, why faith matters 1, rabbi david j. Its not unusual for me to listen to these debates, though im not. The party will go on without you february 26, 2011 posted by ezra resnick in religion. Rabbi david wolpe admits some of the terms he uses in his new book. Rabbi wolpe is the author of eight books, including the national bestseller making loss matter. Ive been watching this, and tentatively impressed by both wolpe and harris.
Sam harris and rabbi david wolpe debate the topic does god exist. Sam harris, famous atheist author and intellectual demolishes the charismatic rabbi david wolpes claim that science cant measure a good life, and talks about the bloody origins of religion. Against such an existence were christopher hitchens and sam harris, interspersedly seated between rabbis david wolpe and shavit artson who argued the opposing view. Afterlife debate w christopher hitchens, sam harris, rabbi david. A debate between bestselling authors rabbi david wolpe and sam harris. Wolpes work has been profiled in the new york times, and he is a. He famously debated reformconservativenonorthodox, rabbi wolpe theres another funny vide.
The american jewish university hosted authors sam harris and rabbi david wolpe to discuss the existence of god and the role of religion and faith in society. Christopher hitchens, sam harris, david wolpe, bradley artson shavit. I can say that i became interested to read more by david wolpe based on some very intelligent answers that he gave during a debate with sam harris about the existence of god. Samuel benjamin harris born april 9, 1967 is an american author, neuroscientist, philosopher, and podcast host. He was named the most influential rabbi in america by newsweek magazine and one of the 50 most influential jews in the world by the jerusalem post. I felt that wolpe was out of control in this debate.
Rabbi wolpe s faith takes on atheists and fanatics alike page 1 of 2. Sam harris the rabbi says that and sam goes on for a while about why hes dumb. Audiobook audiobook chapters physical digital the four horsemen the conversation that sparked an atheist revolution islam and the future of tolerance a dialogue waking up a guide to spirituality without religion lying free will. Rabbi dovid harris born 1945 is an orthodox rabbi who along with rabbi akiva grunblatt, serves as corosh hayeshiva deans at the yeshivas rabbeinu yisrael meir hakohen. This whole book can be read through in a couple of hours, and thats good because i didnt get much out of it.
So, i guess for me one of the problems that i have traditionally had with like the sam harris school of interpretation, rabbi david wolpe 18. Sam harris is a neuroscientist, philosopher, new york times bestselling author, host of the making sense podcast, and creator of the waking up course. The american jewish university hosted authors sam harris and rabbi david wolpe to discuss the existence of god and the role of religion and. In his book he listed such posited causes as the israeli occupation of the west bank and gazathe collusion of western. Wolpe blends the powerful personal story of his struggles with his own faith with a poignant response to the new atheists that reveals just how important faith in modern society.
Rabbi david wolpe was named the most influential rabbi in the country by newsweek magazine in 2012. Sam harris v rabbi david wolpe does god exist full. Join sam harris as he explores some of the most important questions about the human mind, society, and current events. Wolpe born 1958 is the max webb senior rabbi of sinai temple.
Rabbi david wolpe, of sinai temple, is the author of teaching your children about god and why be jewish. Rabbi wolpe seems to have decided to fight fire with yogurt. In the moral landscape 2010, harris argues that science can help answer moral problems and aid human wellbeing. Sam harris debates racism with woke author duration. Sep 07, 2014 sam harris, famous atheist author and intellectual demolishes the charismatic rabbi david wolpe s claim that science cant measure a good life, and talks about the bloody origins of religion. The american jewish university invited me, as an editor of articles on religion, to moderate a debate this fall between author sam harris and rabbi david wolpe, and for. Blog sam harris debates, lectures, interviews, essays. If this blog or johns books have been helpful to you please consider making a donation. From the most salient questions about our national identity and place in the world, to fundamental concerns about technology, religion, the economy, and public policy, intelligence squared u. Richard dawkins, sam harris, and christopher hitchens, and attempts to answer their most strident criticisms about religion and faith by. Wolpe tried every trick in the book, just like any meat packer defending his factory job might. Sam harris vs rabbi sam harris demolishes rabbi david. Over the christmas break, i spent a fair amount of time bingewatching jordan peterson videos.
The famed atheist doesnt think israel should exist as a jewish state, but explains why he sides with them now. Sam harris on deriving ought from is by means of science. Rabbi wolpes faith takes on atheists and fanatics alike. Thanks so much there are several different ways to donate. Sep 16, 2014 david wolpe, whom newsweek called the most influential rabbi in america, takes a fresh look at biblical david in an attempt to find coherence in his seemingly contradictory actions and impulses. Of the many peterson videos, the ones that intrigued me the most featured his dialogues with sam harris, one of the four horsemen of the new atheism and perhaps the most strident critic of religion on the scene today. In this book, the author takes on those who are called the new atheists. Of the many peterson videos, the ones that intrigued me the most featured his dialogues with sam harris, one of the four horsemen of the new atheism and perhaps the. Jan 12, 2011 yesterday i listened to a debate between sam harris and rabbi david wolpe. Speaking at the 2007 aspen ideas festival video on jul.
How to avoid the clash of civilizations by jonathan sacks. Christopher hitchens and sam harris debated rabbi david wolpe and rabbi bradley shavit artson in a panel discussion. In a recent debate between christopher hitchens, sam harris, rabbi david wolpe and rabbi bradley artson on the topic is there an afterlife. He was infuriated by a wave of bestselling books by atheists, including sam harris, christopher hitchens and richard dawkins, all glibly sure that god does not exist and that faith is for fools, he says. Waking up a guide to spirituality without religion by sam. Hitchens, wolpe, harris, artson and the afterlife excerpts.
Yes but he criticises islam most because of its threat to america and the world, then christianity because of its influence in america, and then judaism. His book the end of faith 2004, was a critique of organized religion. With a foreword by rick warren, new york times bestselling author of the purpose driven life, why faith matters is an articulate and muchneeded nondenominational defense. Christopher hitchens and rabbi shmuley boteach debate on. He is a prominent figure in the yeshiva world and speaks annually at the torah umesorah national society for hebrew day schools convention. In this episode of the waking up podcast, sam harris speaks with eric weinstein and ben shapiro about the breakdown of shared values, the problem with identity politics, religion, free will, the primacy of reason, and many other topics. He is also no stranger to high profile debates with atheists like christopher hitchens and sam harris.
His work touches on a wide range of topics, including rationality, religion, ethics, free will, neuroscience, meditation, philosophy of mind, politics, terrorism. A short, beautiful book about the power and promises of faith. Dec 29, 2007 the american jewish university invited me, as an editor of articles on religion, to moderate a debate this fall between author sam harris and rabbi david wolpe, and for about 90 minutes they. Sam harris and rabbi david wolpe guest contributor friendly. He famously debated reformconservativenonorthodox, rabbi wolpe theres another funny video where he went to a very secular synagogue called university. How harmless is it to post an article about why people should read the bible on a site devoted to religion.
Sam harris and the myth of perfectly rational thought wired. The panel consists of christopher hitchens, author of god is not great, rabbi david wolpe, author of why faith matters, sam harris, author of letter to a christian nation and rabbi bradley shavit artson, author of the everyday torah. Recently he posted an interesting meme on his facebook page. Interview with rabbi david wolpe the book of doctrines and.
Sam harris vs rabbi sam harris demolishes rabbi david wolpe. I scored the debate in favour of wolpe clear cut, yes harris made a few good points, but not when addressing the moot of the existence of god. Share david wolpe quotations about soul, prayer and heart. When a rabbi airs his no respect complaints jewish week. I like to call it my night with the atheist and the rabbi. Ill throw you a scattershot of points here didnt read the linked articl. Rob eshman, editorin chief of the jewish journal will moderate this stellar panel. Famed rabbi sets out to dispel myths about faith in new book j. Christopher hitchens and sam harris debate rabbis david wolpe. The party will go on without you no right to believe. Hitchens and harris debate others is there an afterlife.
I have previously read rabbi wolpe s book teaching your children about god, and i very much liked his kind, gentle tone. Another time, i moderated a panel on which hitchens, rabbi wolpe, rabbi brad artson and author sam harris. My first moments with christopher hitchens were interrupted by a man who pointed out that on the back of my book on faith. The evening would have been better billed as a conversation, given its format, but it.
I was disappointed that the moderator didnt do a better job of keeping wolpe under control. Yesterday i listened to a debate between sam harris and rabbi david wolpe. Sam harris debating rabbi david wolpe on does god exist. Rabbi david wolpe and rabbi bradley artson response to critics of the moral landscape among the many quandaries a writer must face after publishing a controversial book is the question of how, or whether, to respond to criticism.
Wolpe makes the case for religion and rebuts recent critiques of religion by a quartet of prominent atheists called the new atheists. Wolpe, who has written several books on faith, acknowledged that virulent forms of. Sam harris and rabbi david wolpe guest contributor. Sam harris narrow view of science is wrong huffpost. Aug 28, 2019 yes but he criticises islam most because of its threat to america and the world, then christianity because of its influence in america, and then judaism. Dec 29, 2007 the american jewish university hosted authors sam harris and rabbi david wolpe to discuss the existence of god and the role of religion and faith in society. There seems to be a lot of viewing of hitchens debates going around, but as someone mentioned here i forget who, sorry, sam harris is really the way to go for strong debating. His congregation attracts a thousand worshippers on a shabbat morning and at its peak his friday night service attracted 1500. Sep 01, 2008 as an answer to writers like harris and hitchens and dawkins oh my. Rabbi boteach says hitchens, with whom he has debated four times in front of large audiences, deserves the fee because he is a big draw, but that harris is not. If you find sam s work valuable, please consider subscribing to this website. Sam harris is the author of the end of faith and letter to a christian nation.
Oct 12, 2017 my assessment of harris as an academic ph. On february 15th i attended the debate is there an afterlife. Sam harris author wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. He was constantly cutting harris off and making sarcastic remarks during sam s responses. Its not unusual for me to listen to these debates, though im not quite sure what deeply felt need i have that. Wolpe is the max webb senior rabbi of sinai temple. Christopher hitchens and sam harris debated rabbi david wolpe and rabbi bradley shavit artson in a panel. I think he recognizes that faith doesnt win people over through intricate arguments, so much as through stories, metaphors, and life experience. The author questions why david holds such an exalted place in history and legend, and then proceeds to unravel his complex character based on. Dec 29, 2011 in this recent whizin center for continuine education program, leading advocates for atheism, christopher hitchens and sam harris square off against newsweek top rabbis, david wolpe and bradley. Rabbi wolpes goal in why faith matters is to make the case for the richness of a life infused with faith, not to advocate for a particular set of beliefs indeed, the controversial pastor rick warren contributes the books foreword.
1450 1543 49 266 782 1368 685 203 45 505 1294 220 1355 505 1103 690 860 806 632 896 578 972 1521 855 1312 186 1369 303 157 1247 1557 1257 1481 1373 336 1270 375 795 149 347